Skip to content

Plain-language guides to child-safe family travel and responsible tourism

Orphanage Tourism: Why Many Experts Advise Families to Avoid It

orphanage tourism

If you’re weighing a visit or volunteer stint abroad, orphanage tourism is worth a second look. Many child-welfare experts advise families to avoid it, because well-meant visits can fuel harm to the children involved.

This page is part of the wider guide to responsible tourism for families.

Item Value
Children in orphanages and institutional care worldwide (UNICEF estimate, 2017) At least 2.7 million
Children living in orphanages who have at least one surviving parent 80%
Cost of funding an orphanage versus community and family care (East and Southern Africa study, 2006) On average 10 times more expensive
Australia and criminalising the recruitment of children into orphanages First country to do so, in 2018

These figures come from NPR’s January 2020 report and a Save the Children blog post. They can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What is orphanage tourism?

Researchers define orphanage tourism as visits or volunteering in orphanages as part of a holiday or tourist experience, as set out in a peer-reviewed review in Frontiers in Sustainable Tourism. The review uses the term for both short visits and long-term volunteering.

In practice, the format varies. NPR describes preplanned trips with a full week at the institution, arranged by an organization, church or travel agency. It also describes a vacationer setting aside a couple of hours to visit and play with the children.

The review calls orphanage tourism a consumer product: it sits where orphanage operators’ wish for international funding meets tourists’ and volunteers’ wish to give back. That is a useful way to see why it persists even when everyone involved means well.

The idea is not new. The same Frontiers review says the concept was first documented in academic research in 2010, and that in 2014 the Better Care Network commissioned a comprehensive study of how and why it was occurring.

Why do many experts advise families to avoid it?

The concern is less about visitors’ intentions than about what their demand can set in motion. Several sources point to the same handful of problems:

  • Most of the children have family. NPR reports that a Save the Children report published in 2009 estimated that at least four in five children in institutional care have at least one living parent.
  • Demand can create supply. The Better Care Network notes UNICEF’s concern that in Cambodia orphanages had become so lucrative that tourist and volunteer demand had created supply. Tourism was, in that view, unwittingly financing orphanages populated by children who were not orphans.
  • Money can attract recruitment. According to NPR’s summary of the U.S. Department of State’s 2018 Trafficking in Persons report, the money led unscrupulous institutions to promise food, education or a better life in order to recruit children from families (NPR).
  • Untrained access to vulnerable children. Save the Children says it is worried about unskilled and untrained volunteers having access to extremely vulnerable children.
  • Institutions cost more. The same organisation’s 2006 study in East and Southern Africa found that, on average, funding an orphanage was 10 times more expensive than community and family care.

Save the Children adds that these institutions are poorly regulated and are doing a job that families could do with the right support (source).

What does research say about children’s development?

A major study of Romanian orphanages, published in 2009, found that institutionalisation of children under the age of three is one of the biggest threats to early brain development. Save the Children says the effects are similar to those of severe malnutrition, lead poisoning and drug use during pregnancy.

The Frontiers review looked at a decade of research on orphanage tourism specifically. Its authors conclude that the limited benefits for children involved are outweighed by child protection concerns, together with negative impacts on child agency, rights and development.

Two children hold hands while walking along a narrow wooden crossing surrounded by greenery.

Family networks matter here. Andrea Freidus, an anthropologist at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, found in her research in southern Africa that extended families and social networks are “very resilient” as an alternative to institutionalization, according to NPR.

What have governments and international guidance said?

The United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of the Child declares that every child has the right to grow up in a family environment. Its Guidelines for the Alternative Care of Children state that institutional care should be a temporary “last resort” for the “shortest possible duration,” as NPR explains.

As of NPR’s January 2020 report, the British government had updated its travel advice to discourage tourists from visiting or volunteering in orphanages, saying it could have “serious unintended consequences.” NPR also reported that the U.K., Australia and the U.S. had taken public stands, and that the Dutch parliament had held a debate on the practice and its connection to human trafficking.

In 2018, Australia became the first country to criminalize recruiting children into orphanages as a form of slavery, per the same NPR report. Laws and advice change, so look up your own government’s latest travel advice before you go.

Better ways to help children and families

Experts are not telling you to stay home. Save the Children says travel and working with others can teach you a lot, but it advises careful research and asking the right questions about safeguarding and protecting children.

James Kassaga Arinaitwe, co-founder of Teach for Uganda, put the alternative this way to NPR: “If you really want to help them, help their extended families take care of them.” The same logic runs through ReThink Orphanages, a collaborative initiative set up by Save the Children and the Better Care Network to discourage volunteering in orphanages and promote more responsible alternatives.

Before you book any trip that involves children, ask the organiser:

  • Will volunteers or visitors have direct contact with children, and who supervises it?
  • What safeguarding and child protection rules apply to visitors?
  • Does the programme support children to stay with their families and communities?
  • Where do fees and on-site donations go?

You can read more about family volunteering abroad in a separate guide on this site.

If something you saw while travelling worried you, there is also a guide on how to report child safety concerns when traveling. This site is independent and does not take reports itself.

Frequently asked questions

Is a short visit different from long-term volunteering?

Show answer

Researchers treat both as orphanage tourism. The Frontiers review groups brief drop-in visits and longer placements under one label, so a quick stop to meet the children is not exempt from the concerns above.

Are the children in orphanages usually orphans?

Show answer

Often they are not. Estimates cited by NPR suggest that the large majority have a living parent, which is why many experts favour supporting families rather than placing children in institutions.

Does donating to an orphanage help?

Show answer

Gifts can have side effects. NPR notes that visits can bring money in through fees and on-site donations, while Save the Children warns that over-reliance on orphanages, often funded by well-meaning visitors, can pull extended family networks apart.

What if a school, church or tour group plans a visit?

Show answer

Share the safeguarding questions listed earlier with the organiser before anyone commits. You can also suggest an activity that does not involve visiting children in care.